Saturday, September 22, 2018

Welcome to 28 Barbary Lane

Ahh, San Francisco. Like the Land of Oz and the Garden of Eden, the fabled City by the Bay is a magical and mythical destination, a real-life come-as-you-are party, a place where you can let your hair down, be yourself and pursue your own idea of happiness—and maybe even taste some forbidden fruit along the way. No wonder Angels in America playwright Tony Kushner used the city as his prototype for Heaven.

There could be no better setting for the odyssey of Armistead Maupin’s Tales of the City (1993). Based on his marvelous series of books, originally serialized as a fictional column in The San Francisco Chronicle, this groundbreaking 1993 miniseries is set in the San Francisco of 1976, that brief shining sweet spot after Vietnam and Watergate and before the spectre of AIDS crashed the party of free sexual expression.

A view from Russian Hill by Warzau Wynn

Dealing with themes of homosexuality, transsexualism, drugs and a variety of other perversions and persuasions, and featuring unapologetically adult language and nudity, the series caused an uproar with its first controversial airing on PBS. The ultra right-wing Moral Majority blasted the series for its “obscene” subject matter and campaigned vigorously against federal funding for the arts for public television. With all that political kafuffle, no wonder Tales remains so popular with the outcasts, sinners and heathens of the world.

Tales of the City is the best kind of soap opera, peopled with unforgettable characters that audiences grow to love and care about, fantastic stories made addictive with byzantine plot twists, metaphysical themes and synchronicities, all imbued with an underlying philosophy of love and tolerance. Gorgeously produced, intelligently written and brilliantly acted, this is a series I find myself watching again and again.

Good neighbors: Mona (Chloe Webb, Mary Ann (Laura Linney) and Mouse (Marcus D'Amico)

Olympia Dukakis (Moonstruck, Steel Magnolias) is iconic as the mysterious and strange landlady Anna Madrigal, “the mother of us all,” who makes each tenant in her Barbary Lane building a member of a new family unit, offering unconditional love and acceptance—as well as a welcoming joint taped to their doors, a housewarming gift from her own overgrown garden of cannabis plants.  
“You’re one of us now,” she whispers to new tenant Mary Ann, urging her to “bite into that lotus,” quoting Tennyson (“Eating the lotus day by day…”). When asked if she has an objection to pets, permissive Mrs. Madrigal replies, “Dear, I have no objection to anything…”

Unconditional love: Olympia Dukakis as Mrs. Anna Madrigal

Of course, like all denizens of Barbary Lane, Mrs. Madrigal has her secrets…chief among them (spoiler alert) that she spent the better part of her life as a man named Andy before having a sex change. (In the 1970s when the book was written, and even into the 1990s when the series was produced, this was a shocking secret to reveal…but today we take such things in stride. This mild spoiler is only one delicious plot twist in an intertwining crazy quilt of sordid but entertaining lives.) “We don’t have people like that in Cleveland,” Mary Ann comments ruefully.

Born innocent: Laura Linney as Mary Ann Singleton

Laura Linney (Ozark, The Truman Show) brings to life the character of sweet and naive Mary Ann Singleton of Cleveland, Ohio, who surveys her new hometown with wide-eyed wonder and curiosity. Through the course of the series, goody-two-shoes Mary Ann will nevertheless end up having an affair with a married man, smoking the devil's weed and singlehandedly taking down a sleazy private investigator who threatens to reveal Mrs. Madrigal’s identity as a transsexual.

Barbara Garrick (Working Girl) steals every scene she’s in with her humorously tense and agitated performance as DeeDee Halcyon Day, a neurotic and uptight heiress who moves in the same social circles as infamous fellow San Franciscan Patty Hearst.

Unstable: Barbara Garrick as DeeDee Halcyon Day

The narcissist: Thomas Gibson as Beauchamp Day

Marcus D’Amico strikes the perfect note of boyish vulnerability as Michael (Mouse) Tolliver, hopeless romantic and homosexual, looking for Mr. Right in all the wrong places. Handsomely heroic William Campbell is Dr. Jon Fielding, the doctor Michael falls in love with (a character every good soap opera needs!).

Paul Gross is Brian Hawkins, one of Mrs. Madrigal’s rare heterosexual tenants—a good-looking womanizer who strikes up a gay-straight alliance with Michael. The pair become fast friends as they cruise the city’s nightspots for horny guys and gals.

Sexual healing: Mouse and Dr. Jon Fielding (William Campbell)

Straight and available: Paul Gross as Brian Hawkins

The eccentric: Parker Posey as Connie Bradshaw

Chloe Webb (Sid and Nancy, Practical Magic) is perfect as the kooky Mona Ramsey, a free spirit who goes around topless, practices yoga and transcendental meditation and reveals lesbian tendencies, falling for moody fashion model D’Orothea Wilson, played by Cynda Williams. Mona gets Mary Ann a job at Halcyon, where she works as an advertising copywriter. 

Rounding out the cast are a host of brilliant actors: Donald Moffatt (Clear and Present Danger) is Edgar Halcyon, a wealthy but terminally ill businessman who falls in love with Mrs. Madrigal. Thomas Gibson (Eyes Wide Shut) is unforgettable as Beauchamp (pronounced Beacham) Day, Halcyon’s bisexual playboy of a son-in-law, who cheats on his wife with anybody handy. Parker Posey (Waiting for Guffman, Best in Show) is delightfully offbeat as Connie Bradshaw, Mary Ann’s classmate and friend from Ohio who introduces her to the '70s San Franciscan’s daily diet of of disco, casual sex and supermarket cruising.

As well, you’ll run across a host of quirky cameos by the likes of Edie Adams, Rod Steiger, Karen Black, Bob Mackie, Ian McKellan, a young Janeane Garafolo and many more, adding piquant flavor and spice to the mix of outlandish characters and situations. 

Cynda Williams, Chloe Webb, Marcus D'Amico and William Campbell

Tales of the City transports you to a bicentennial red, white and blue mid-1970s where you can almost smell the lemon candles, incense and marijuana in the air, as you boogie to classic disco and watch Mary Tyler Moore and Mary Hartman. It’s a freewheeling era of birth control, feminism and casual pickups—cruising for sex in the aisles of a Safeway supermarket. 

Naturally, the central character of the series is the hilly, romantic, mysterious gothic city referenced in the title itself. San Francisco has inspired many a storyteller—it’s a progressive sanctuary that birthed the hippie movement, the Summer of Love and the quest for LGBTQ rights, a place where they were practicing tai chi in the park 40 years before it became fashionable. 

Green thumb: Mrs Madrigal in the garden, tending her cannabis plants

San Francisco is a very special city; “Nobody is from here,” someone comments to Mary Ann. Indeed, Armistead Maupin himself is a San Franciscan transplanted from the Deep South, and to the author the city is a very metaphysical place indeed. Mrs. Madrigal refers to her entire adopted family as reincarnated citizens of Atlantis.

Much of the series was filmed on location here, and the action centers around the ramshackle apartment house at 28 Barbary Lane—a fictional address on real-life Russian Hill, off Lombard Street, and indeed Maupin’s plots and subplots meander and twist much like the famous crooked thoroughfare itself. Homages to Alfred Hitchcock’s Vertigo abound in the series, from Bernard Herrmann’s music to locations including Kim Novak’s Mason Street apartment building, the Golden Gate Bridge, the Legion D’Honneur and Muir Redwood Forest.

Maupin’s Tales continued to unfold with the sequels More Tales of the City (1998) and Further Tales of the City (2001) produced by Showtime. The second and third series introduced a host of new characters (including Mrs. Madrigal’s zany brothel-running mom Mother Mucca) and storylines from the Maupin books, as well as new actors playing familiar characters. But fan favorites Laura Linney, Olympia Dukakis and Barbara Garrick reprised their roles in both series, establishing a strong through-line of continuity.

In 2011 a musical version was mounted at San Francisco’s American Conservatory Theatre featuring music by Jake Shears of Scissor Sisters fame. The opening night was attended by Laura Linney and Armistead Maupin (and my best pal Eric and I were there in the audience that night, too, at the Geary Street theater!).

Author, author: Dukakis with Armistead Maupin

Good news—Maupin’s Tales will continue to be told on screen. Netflix has ordered 10 new episodes (presumably based on the later Maupin books, the last of which were published in 2010 and 2014) that will again star Linney as Mary Ann, Dukakis as Mrs. Madrigal and Garrick as DeeDee. I eagerly await the series reboot in 2019.  In the meantime, for Tales virgins, the original 1993 series is currently running on Acorn TV.

Celebrating all the kinks and peccadilloes and foibles of the human experience, Tales of the City celebrates the imperfect art of being human—ultimately, it’s all about people and the love they share. 

This is an entry in the Gender Bending the Rules Blogathon, cohosted by my friend Quiggy at his engaging and prolific Midnite Drive-In blog. Thanks so much to all who have participated—I look forward to reading everyone’s entries!


  1. I SO want to see this now. I'm a connoisseur of the 70's culture especially the parts I missed out on growing up in very small town America. (I was born in 1961, so most of the 70's I lived a child and teenager; too young to really be aware of my surroundings.) My library has the series on DVD. I'll put it on my list after I get through with the ones I already have checked out. They limit me to 5 at a time and I already have 5...:-( I can imagine I'll be wishing i had a time machine, much like I often do when watching movies from that era.

  2. You will LOVE this then, Quiggy, guaranteed. This is the TV miniseries as art, before-its-time television at its very best. Laura Linney, Olympia Dukakis and cast are unforgettable! I am so glad I have finally had a chance to write about this masterpiece of a series.

    Thanks for hosting this fabulously-themed blogathon. I am having a blast!

  3. I just reread this. Bob Mackie is in it? The costume designer for Carol Burnett? He of the curtain rod dress? Didn't even know he was an actor. Also, this is the 70's. Where are the characters with the porn star mustaches? (Or is that a little too late by the timeline?) Didn't notice any in the pictures you posted...

  4. I remember reading the first book many many moons ago, and enjoying it (I think), but I never caught up with the later books, and the TV series is completely unknown to me. I don't remember if I even remember it (now that's a sentence!). Seems to me if it was on PBS I would have wanted to watch it, but I'm just drawing a blank -- maybe it was before I had a VCR and there was something else I or my partner wanted to watch? Like Quiggy, I will have to see if the library has a copy or if it's on youtube. Thanks for reminding me of this. As usual, your post was so beautifully done, Chris! Sounds like this show might be a treat!

    Which would you say is better -- the books or the TV shows?

  5. Quiggy - yup, the same Bob Mackie who designed for Cher and Carol Burnett- one of his only acting roles.
    And to answer your second question, the mustaches start to appear more prominently in the second series, More Tales--and Mouse is played by a different actor who is dark haired with a classic 70s 'stache...

  6. Bill - I think you are going to love the series; it is one of the rare adaptations that are just as entertaining as the books.
    I do recommend the entire series of books by Maupin, though for even more of the interior life and history of all these rich characters. I first saw the series, then started reading the books.
    Enjoy--let me know your thoughts about them!
    Thanks as always for stopping by and participating in our blogathon--you rock!!

  7. I really enjoyed reading your article. You wrote with such knowledge and affection. Like others here, Tales of the City is just a title to me; something I had read about but either didn't air locally or - wait, it was on TV in the 90s? My kids were small and didn't watch much that wasn't animated in those days. Time for some catch-up.

  8. Hi Caftan Woman - the series debuted on PBS in January of 1994, I believe; it may have been preempted in some midwestern states because of the sensitive subject matter, but not sure.
    This is where I fell totally in love with Laura Linney!
    Thanks for reading and commenting, and for your participation in our blogathon!