Monday, May 16, 2016

The Queen of Mean

When a 2016 presidential candidate was recently described as “Lucifer in the flesh,” the first image to flash into my mind was not a politician at all, but rather a slim, elegant and impeccably dressed woman played in a movie by Meryl Streep.

Based upon Lauren Weisberger’s roman a clef novel, inspired by a stint as assistant to none other than Vogue maven Anna Wintour, The Devil Wears Prada (2006) is given a slick and entertaining film treatment by director David Frankel and features fabulous fashions, sumptuous production design and engaging performances by a bevy of attractive and talented actors. But the film really belongs to just one person, in the eponymous title role.

Meryl Streep as the Devil incarnate

The character of Runway editrix Miranda Priestly joins the ranks of cinema’s greatest female bosses from hell including Joan Crawford’s Amanda Farrow in The Best of Everything, Susan Hayward’s Helen Lawson in Valley of the Dolls, and Sigourney Weaver’s Katharine Parker in Working Girl. Miranda is brought to terrifying life with brilliant precision by the most multifaceted actress of all, Meryl Streep, who earned a richly deserved Academy Award nomination for the role. (If only she had won that third Oscar for this juicy part, and not as a bucktoothed and boring Margaret Thatcher!)

Miranda Priestly is everything an iconic screen villain should be—an irresistible combination of beauty, brains and cruelty. She’s narcissistic and self-centered; talented and driven; ruthless and cold-blooded;  in short, a glamorous embodiment of pure and unadulterated evil. 

Miranda Priestly, editor of Runway magazine

Streep takes great pains to fashion a completely original character in Miranda, who looks and sounds nothing at all like Anna Wintour. Instead, Streep cleverly makes her antiheroine a soft-spoken dragon lady; her vicious putdowns and catty remarks are all uttered sotto voce, with ladylike deportment. But her murmured asides are skillfully designed for systematically belittling, criticizing and dismissing her long-suffering staff, who exist only to please her. But the mere pursing of her lips in displeasure is “a catastrophe.” Her opinion is the only one that matters.

Anne Hathaway as Andrea Sachs

Giving an endlessly long string of orders to her assistants in a hushed monotone, demolishing deadlines and rescheduling meetings, the Queen Bee then sighs with weary disappointment when her worker bees and drones fail to fulfill her commands quickly or efficiently enough. “It’s baffling to me, confusing to me“ she sighs in quiet exasperation, “Why is no one ready?”

Stylish, poised and supremely self-possessed, and fortified by a healthy case of borderline personality disorder, Miranda cuts a swath of pure terror through the Runway offices. Her few redeeming qualities — talent, a singular focus and a steely determination to survive in the shark-infested waters of the New York fashion pool—do little to offset her hard-as-nails persona.

Here she comes: "Gird your loins"
Described by other characters as “a notorious sadist” who is “not happy unless everyone around her is panicked, nauseous or suicidal,” Miranda is as iconic as Cruella deVil and Mommie Dearest, minus the cartoon campiness. Streep imbues the character with disturbing reality.

Perfectly playing Snow White to Streep’s glamorous Wicked Queen is Anne Hathaway in one of her most winning roles. As fresh-faced Northwestern graduate Andrea Sachs, who reluctantly takes the job of second assistant to Miranda, Hathaway arrives fully prepared to pay her dues, but doesn’t yet realize she’ll be paying in tears, toil and blood. (And by changing every aspect of her appearance to measure up to the fashion industry’s impossibly high standards. Hard to believe that the willowy Hathaway is shamed for eating and described as “fat” by her new coworkers.)

Andrea and Emily (Emily Blunt)

Nigel (Stanley Tucci) and Miranda

The ice queen puts her new assistant through her paces, treating her like dirt when she acknowledges her presence at all, damning her with the faintest of praise. Like a starving animal, Andrea eagerly laps up the few crumbs of approval that are offered by her new employer. Then, in true Faustian fairy tale fashion, Andrea becomes the girl Miranda wants her to be, ditching her friends, lover and personal integrity in the process.

Though Andrea enjoys a personal happy ending, walking out on Miranda and getting her dream job as a newspaper reporter, the villain is far from vanquished at the close of this story. Ultimately, it is her power that allows Andrea to get her next job; ironically confirming that Miranda’s influence will probably continue, undiminished, perhaps indefinitely. Evil triumphs!

Nate (Adrian Grenier) and Andy
Simon Baker as Christian

Though Streep and Hathaway dominate here, they’re bolstered by an impressive cast and production that make the film an utter delight to watch again and again. Brilliant supporting performances by Emily Blunt as a bitchy Miranda mini-me and Stanley Tucci as a twitchy gay fashion director (sharp-tongued but with a heart of gold, of course!) are perfect foils for Miranda and Andrea. Adrian Grenier and Simon Baker add some tempting male eye candy to the proceedings. Costume designer Patricia Field (Sex and the City) captures the fashion zeitgeist of that moment, and the soundtrack and cinematography capture the mood and magic of the New York and Paris fashion worlds.

Though Meryl Streep has aced practically every kind of role imaginable, like most actors she really seems to relish this rare opportunity to play an out-and-out evil bitch. And a decade later, it remains one of her most memorable roles. 

Thanks to Speakeasy, Silver Screenings and Shadows and Satin for hosting The Great Villain Blogathon of 2016. So much fun to participate!


  1. Brava! LOVED your review, and completely agree with it. Meryl Streep is perfect in this role, and is such a joy to watch.

    Thanks for joining the Villain Blogathon, and for bringing "The Queen of Mean" with you. It's a brilliant choice.

  2. Thank YOU for your amazing Blogathon; am having a blast reading all the entries. It's going to be an awesome week of cinema's greatest anti-heroes!
    It's an honor to participate!

  3. Love this choice, a villain you can easily meet in real life and a great performance. Thanks for joining in!

  4. We have all had bosses with some of these qualities, right, Kristina? Thanks so much for hosting the Blogathon and for stopping by!

  5. Anonymous4:52 PM

    Loved your post! I've only seen this movie once, but I thoroughly enjoyed it, and your top-notch treatment has me wanting to check it out again. (And I am totally stealing that gif at the end -- I could look at that all day, LOL) Thanks so much for taking part in our blogathon this year!

  6. Thanks so much for hosting the Blogathon, and for your kind words. Hope you will watch this delightful film again's truly one of my guilty pleasures!

  7. Hey Chris, where ya been? You've got some catching up to do, man. If you are interested in film noir I have a blogathon for you to join over at The Midnite Drive-In. And you can catch up on the other posts.

    Obviously I've never seen this one, but I do like Streep. Ever since I saw her in The Deer Hunter. Burt her films are usually on a different trajectory from my interests. (If only she'd sign on to be a villain in some superhero movie...)

  8. Chris, as usual, another beautifully written post. I didn't like the flick as much as you did, but your analysis was excellent. One thing I thought was funny about the movie was the way everyone put down Anne Hathaway's fashion sense but never seemed to notice how very beautiful she was.

    As for Streep playing a Marvel or DC super-villainess as the gentleman suggested? Sadly, she may be too old now to play the most famous of them, although she could always do Madame Masque in Iron Man and wear a mask, but that seems to defeat the purpose. Maybe Mystique's lover, Destiny? [You probably have no idea what I'm talking about, LOL, but my fellow comment-poster got me started!] Anyway, she did play a witch in "Into the Woods" and that may have to do.

    I've never participated in a "blog-a-thon" although they sound interesting. I think I did do, or at least got dragged along, a blog barhop once, but that had little to do with movies.

    All my best, Bill

  9. Hi, Quiggy, Streep is indeed versatile! She has not yet played a superhero, but has already mastered the action adventure genre--remember The River Wild with Kevin Bacon, where she paddled through the rapids and saved the whole family?

    Thanks for stopping by - I appreciate your support!

  10. Thank you, Bill, for your kind words and your support! I know this film is not everyone's cup of tea--back in the day they would have called it a "women's picture"--but there is no denying that Meryl Streep, as usual, rises above the material and makes it memorable. She is a cinema alchemist!

    I'd love to go blog-hopping with you sometime, how exactly does that work? Would you be the designated driver? ;-)

  11. As I recall all of the bloggers went from bar to bar to bar to bar and by the end of the evening few could remember the names of their blogs or be coherent enough to promote/talk about them. But it was fun! No designated driver needed in Manhattan, although some people had to be poured into cabs, LOL!

  12. I really enjoyed reading your review! Villain describes Meryl Streeps character perfectly, although I never thought of her in those terms before. But your post proves that she definitely is! It made me want to watch this movie again, and watch for the things you pointed out. Thanks so much!

  13. Hi Shari - thank you so much for your visit and comments! This is a movie I love to watch again and again, hope you enjoy it next time you watch it!

  14. I'm a bit late to the party here, but had to chime in how much I enjoyed your covering one of my favorite Streep performances. Years ago I thought Kevin Spacey in "Swimming With Sharks" was the most terrifying vision of an employer I'd ever seen; that was until "Prada."
    Excellent assessment of Streep fashioning a whole new kind of monster, and I like your calling her an antiheroine. - as chilling a character as she is, Streep somehow mines the humanity.
    Thanks, Chris, for another excellent essay and a fun spotlight on one of my own personal fave screen villains!

  15. Hi Ken! Thanks so much for coming by! YES, I too LOVE the villainous boss from hell as played by Kevin Spacey in Swimming with Sharks...a perfect parallel to Streep's regal bitchery...
    I do adore the multifaceted and unlimited talents of Streep--I recently counted the Meryl's in my DVD collection and I have more of her performances than of any other star...Julia, Silkwood, Postcards from the Edge, Defending Your Life, Angels in America, and Devil Wears Prada...and there are a few more I still need to buy!
    Thanks again for your kind comments, Ken! I appreciate you!